Blake Lively vs Katy Perry

Katy Perry was spotted in this Smythe’s equestrian coat with a red leopard scarf and metallic gold bag, on her way out to somewhere in London, while Gossip Girl‘s Blake Lively covered up in a similar wool topper on her way to a dinner party hosted by Chanel in New York. Who wore it better? Could Katy have done without that scarf and gold bag or did Blake nail this one..again?