Liv Tyler vs Carey Mulligan in Stella McCartney

Once again a Stella McCartney piece is featuring in one of our polls. Liv Tyler wore this number to the opening of the British label’s new store in New York, at the beginning of the year. The actress wore the two-tone ensemble from the Spring 2012 collection with Givenchy sandals. Liv finished off her outfit with a coat over the dress. Carey Mulligan chose to wear the same dress to the ARK Gala in Hollywood a few weeks ago. The star, who recently married Marcus Mumford, wore the dress with black heels, carrying a blue clutch and wearing some serious bling around her neck.

Grab this designer dress for yourself ($925). Or get a similar look in this cream and black, two tone peplum dress (£26.99).

Liv Tyler reigns supreme in Stella McCartney, winning your votes in this label last time around. This may be Carey Mulligan’s first ever fash-off on here, but could she steal Liv’s limelight? Carey looks gorgeous in the dress and I love how she’s kept her accessories simple. Liv looks great, but I’m disappointed she covered the piece up with a coat. Do you disagree? Tell me why below!

Images courtesy of Zimbio and ElleUK.